Lorenzo Rossi brings his authentic Italian flair to every piece he crafts. As a seasoned pizza owner in Italy, Lorenzo combines his deep culinary expertise with a passion for storytelling.
Discovering the Best Pizza in the Florida Keys
When you think of the Florida Keys, you imagine crystal-clear waters, spectacular sunsets, and a laid-back island vibe. But nestled within this paradise are some of the most delightful and delicious pizza places you’ll find anywhere. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita, a loaded supreme, or something uniquely local, the Keys have a pizza spot for you. Let’s take a culinary journey through some of the top-rated pizza stores in the Florida Keys that promise to satisfy your cravings with their mouth-watering selections.
Upper Crust Pizza
First on the list is Upper Crust Pizza, a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Known for its Tuscan pizza featuring a delightful mix of chicken, bacon, alfredo sauce, tomatoes, spinach, onions, and a generous topping of parmesan, Upper Crust Pizza delivers on both quality and taste. This spot is not just about pizza; it’s about an experience. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff add to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone traveling through the Keys.
Triton Seafood Restaurant
Next, we travel to Triton Seafood Restaurant, not your typical pizza place but a gem that offers an unforgettable pizza experience. The Conch Fra Diavolo Pizza and Pizza Supreme are standout choices, blending fresh seafood with traditional pizza elements in an innovative way. Located conveniently on Overseas Highway, Triton provides a unique twist to pizza that beautifully reflects the local cuisine.
Blu Bistro
At Blu Bistro, located in Marathon, you’ll find a casual yet sophisticated dining environment where the pizzas are as beautiful as they are delicious. With a crispy golden crust and a variety of fresh toppings to choose from, Blu Bistro focuses on the quality of their ingredients, ensuring every bite is as satisfying as the last. It’s a less traditional choice for pizza connoisseurs but entirely worth the visit for its unique culinary approach.
7 Mile Pizzeria
For those who love to customize, 7 Mile Pizzeria offers a DIY pizza experience that can’t be beaten. With a wide array of toppings from chicken and meatballs to jalapenos and picadillo, the possibilities are endless. Coupled with its welcoming atmosphere and reasonable prices, 7 Mile Pizzeria stands out as a top choice for families or anyone looking to tailor their pizza to their exact liking.
Coast to Coast Pizza Company
Bringing a slice of New York to the Florida Keys, Coast to Coast Pizza Company is renowned for its New York-style pizza with a Keys vibe. From traditional Neapolitan pies to inventive new creations, this pizzeria is passionate about delivering the highest quality pizza. It’s the perfect stop for those seeking the comforting taste of classic pizza with a touch of local flair.
Whether you’re a visitor exploring the scenic beauty of the Keys or a local in search of your next favorite meal, these pizza stores offer something for every palate. From seafood-infused pizzas to classic New York styles and personalized creations, the best pizza places in the Florida Keys are sure to turn your meal into a memorable experience. Exploring the vibrant pizza scene is just another reason to love this enchanting part of Florida.
Exploring the Unique Flavors of the Florida Keys’ Finest Pizzerias
The Florida Keys, a string of tropical islands, offers more than just scenic views and recreational water activities. It boasts a hidden culinary treasure trove, particularly for pizza enthusiasts. This section delves into some of the unique flavors and their creators, uncovering what makes each pizzeria a must-visit for anyone seeking to indulge in the best pizzas the Keys have to offer.
A Slice of Paradise and Baypoint Pizza: Local Favorites
A Slice of Paradise, situated in Summerland Key, has been hailed as a top spot by travelers for its outstanding pizza. Their secret lies not just in the fresh ingredients but also in the love and attention to detail put into each pizza. Similarly, Baypoint Pizza, known for its high ratings on Yelp, stands out for its dedication to delivering top-notch pizza experiences. Such local favorites have garnered a loyal following, becoming essential stops for pizza lovers traveling through the Keys.
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria and Roostica: Authentic Italian Experience
For those craving an authentic Italian pizza experience, Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria offers a cozy ambiance reminiscent of a small Italian trattoria. The happy hour, with small pizzas and half-off drinks, is particularly popular among locals and tourists alike. Roostica, located in Key West, is renowned for its Sicilian slices that are both crispy and packed with flavor, promising a genuinely Italian feast in the heart of the Florida Keys.
Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria: A Taste of Innovation
Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria distinguishes itself with its innovative approach to pizza making. Known for its crispy, flavorful pizzas, Clemente’s offers a unique dining experience that combines traditional techniques with creative flair. This establishes Clemente’s as a beacon of culinary innovation in the Florida Keys pizza scene.
Each of these establishments contributes to the rich and diverse pizza landscape in the Florida Keys. They highlight the region’s capacity for culinary excellence, blending traditional and innovative approaches to pizza making. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a pizza that incorporates the fresh seafood of the area, the Florida Keys offers an array of options to satisfy every palate. Together, these pizza stores form a mosaic of flavors that reflect the vibrant culture and rich culinary heritage of the Keys, making them indispensable destinations for any food lover exploring this beautiful region.
Savoring the Crust and Beyond: A Culinary Pizza Tour in the Florida Keys
The culinary canvas of the Florida Keys presents a delightful array of pizza venues, each with its unique spin on this universally loved dish. Beyond the traditional expectations of a pizza, these spots in the Keys invite you to a journey of flavors, crusts, and toppings that emphasize local flair and innovation. Whether you’re in search of a slice that feels like a classic New York pizzeria or a creation that captures the essence of the Keys, there’s a pizzeria waiting to serve you a memorable meal.
Embracing Local Ingredients
What sets the Florida Keys’ pizza scene apart is its commitment to embracing local ingredients, ensuring each slice not only tastes fresh but also reflects the region’s culinary heritage. With the proximity to the ocean, it’s no surprise that seafood often finds its way onto the pizza, offering an authentic Keys experience. From the conch and shrimp toppings at Triton Seafood Restaurant to the locally caught fish specials at Blu Bistro, these ingredients elevate the humble pizza to something extraordinary.
Experiences for Every Pizza Lover
Whether it’s the ambience, the wide selection of toppings, or the unique crust options available, the Keys’ pizzerias cater to a wide audience:
- Family-Friendly Vibes: Places like 7 Mile Pizzeria offer a casual, laid-back atmosphere perfect for family outings. Their DIY pizza options ensure that even the pickiest eaters can craft a meal to their liking.
- Date Night Destinations: For a more intimate dining experience, the quaint setting of Triton Seafood Restaurant, with its gourmet pizza options, sets the stage for a perfect romantic evening.
- Adventures in Dining: For the more adventurous eaters, Coast to Coast Pizza Company offers a fusion of flavors that showcase the creative spirit of the Keys, blending traditional pizza with bold, global influences.
More Than Just Pizza
While pizza is the protagonist, many of these establishments enrich the dining experience with a suite of appetizers, desserts, and beverages that round off the meal beautifully. The option to pair your pizza with a local craft beer, a refreshing salad, or a decadent dessert means that each meal can be a journey through a variety of flavors and textures. Establishments like Coast to Coast Pizza Company pride themselves on their full dining experience, ensuring that every visit is not just about the pizza, but about the memories made around the table.
Exploring the pizza scene in the Florida Keys reveals a fascinating blend of traditional craftsmanship and innovative culinary experiments. Whether you are a purist who believes in the sanctity of a Margherita or an adventurous diner eager to explore new flavor combinations, the Keys offer an array of choices that promise to delight. As you wander through this idyllic chain of islands, let the local pizzerias guide you to unexpected pleasures, making your trip a deliciously unforgettable adventure.
