Lorenzo Rossi brings his authentic Italian flair to every piece he crafts. As a seasoned pizza owner in Italy, Lorenzo combines his deep culinary expertise with a passion for storytelling.
Discovering the Best Pizza in St. Augustine: A Culinary Journey
St. Augustine, Florida, is not just known for its rich history and breathtaking coastal views; it is also home to a tantalizing culinary scene, especially for pizza aficionados. From classic New York-style to authentic Italian wood-fired pizzas, St. Augustine offers a slice of heaven for everyone. This guide will navigate you through the top pizza stores in St. Augustine, ensuring your next pizza outing is nothing short of spectacular.
Pizza Time: A Taste of New York
When it comes to pizza in St. Augustine, Pizza Time is a must-visit. Located in the heart of downtown, this pizzeria has earned national acclaim, ranking as the second-best pizza spot in the country by TripAdvisor. Their secret? A perfect Brooklyn-style pizza with an authentic New York-style crust that will transport you straight to the bustling streets of Brooklyn. Whether you’re craving a simple margherita or a fully loaded slice, Pizza Time has got your cravings covered.
Carmelo’s Marketplace: The Convenience of New York-styled Brick Oven Pizza
Next on the list is Carmelo’s Marketplace, where tradition meets variety. Known for its New York-styled brick oven pizza, this eatery not only serves up a delightful array of toppings but also boasts a full menu of Italian dishes. Its popularity among locals and visitors is testament to its quality and convenience, making it a go-to spot for those seeking variety and authenticity in their Italian dining experience.
Pizzalley’s: A Blend of Café and Pizzeria
Located near the legendary St. Augustine fort, Pizzalley’s offers a unique dining experience that blends the casual atmosphere of a café with the rich flavors of a traditional pizzeria. Known for its gourmet slices and custom-order pies, Pizzalley’s stands out for its comprehensive Italian menu and the option for delivery in select areas. It’s the perfect spot for those who enjoy leisurely dining without compromising on taste.
Borrillo’s Pizzeria and More
For those venturing north of downtown, Borrillo’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem worth discovering. Famous for its specialty pizzas like the Borrillo’s Supreme and the classic margherita, it also offers no-contact delivery to select areas. Borrillo’s diverse menu, coupled with its cozy atmosphere, makes it an ideal spot for a family dinner or a casual hangout with friends, any day of the week.
The culinary journey through St. Augustine’s pizza scene reveals not only the diversity and quality of pizza available but also the city’s dedication to offering memorable dining experiences. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, these top-rated pizza stores are sure to satisfy your appetite for both delicious pizza and the charm of St. Augustine.
Exploring More Top Picks: Pizza Classics and Innovations in St. Augustine
In the quest for the perfect slice in St. Augustine, a city known for its historic charm and culinary diversity, the exploration doesn’t stop at the already mentioned favorites. Each pizza place in this historic city brings its own unique flavor and style to the table, creating an endless array of options for pizza lovers. From traditional family recipes passed down through generations to modern takes on classic pies, St. Augustine’s pizzerias cater to all tastes.
Al’s Pizza: A Beachside Delight
Just a short drive from the historic city center, Al’s Pizza offers a scenic view of the Florida coast along with its delicious pies. Known for their commitment to quality and fresh ingredients, Al’s has perfected the art of Neapolitan and New York-style pizzas. Not limiting their menu to pizza alone, they offer an array of Italian favorites that include calzones, flatbreads, and salads, ensuring a comprehensive dining experience. Open daily, Al’s Pizza combines the serenity of Ponte Vedra Beach with the vibrant flavors of Italy, making it an irresistible stop for anyone visiting the area.
Anthony’s East Coast Pizza: Authentic Italian Flavors
For those in search of a truly traditional Italian experience, Anthony’s East Coast Pizza is the place to be. This family-owned pizzeria prides itself on over 20 years of serving authentic Italian cuisine. With wood-fire pizzas at the heart of their menu, they offer a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of a small Italian village pizzeria. Anthony’s remarkable selection of pizzas, each carefully prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients, showcases their dedication to bringing the genuine taste of Italy to St. Augustine.
Viola’s Pizza, Pasta & Seafood: A Slice of Italian Heaven
Viola’s is a testament to the city’s ability to blend diverse culinary traditions into its fabric. This family-operated restaurant offers more than just pizza; it’s an exploration of various Italian dishes, including pasta and seafood. Their wood-fired pizzas stand out for the authentic ingredients and the love poured into each dish. Viola’s welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu make it an ideal spot for those seeking a meal that extends beyond the traditional pizza experience, promising a taste of Italy with every bite.
Amici Italian Eatery: A Tradition of Hospitality
Another gem in the St. Augustine dining scene is Amici Italian Eatery. Opened by brothers Carmelo and Giuseppe, Amici is renowned for its wood-fire pizzas and unparalleled hospitality. Their menu, featuring over ten pizza options, is a reflection of their passion for Italian cooking and their dedication to making every guest feel like family. Beyond pizza, Amici’s extensive menu includes a variety of traditional Italian dishes, ensuring a delightful culinary journey for all who visit.
St. Augustine’s pizza scene showcases the city’s rich culinary diversity and the shared passion for creating memorable dining experiences. Each pizzeria, with its unique approach to traditional Italian cooking, invites visitors and locals alike to embark on a flavorful journey. As these establishments continue to serve up slices of joy, the quest for the perfect pizza in St. Augustine remains a deliciously endless adventure.
A Taste of the Old City: Hidden Pizza Gems in St. Augustine
The allure of St. Augustine’s pizza scene isn’t limited to just the well-known pizzerias; hidden within this ancient city are gems that offer slices of culinary delight in every bite. These establishments are where tradition meets innovation, creating memorable pizza experiences that stand out even in a city famed for its diverse food culture. Let’s uncover these hidden gems and what makes them worthy of your next pizza adventure.
Romano’s On The Beach: A Seaside Pizza Experience
For those who dream of combining a love for pizza with the serene beauty of the beach, Romano’s On The Beach is a must-visit. What sets Romano’s apart is not just its location but its commitment to delivering over a dozen specialty pizzas. One of their standout offerings is “The Grandma,” a square-shaped, thin crust pizza that’s generously topped with fresh sauce, a drizzle of olive oil, and creamy mozzarella. This seaside pizza haven promises not just a meal, but a delightful experience that compliments the beauty of St. Augustine’s shores.
Antonio’s New York Style Pizza: Crafting Authentic Experiences
Another hidden treasure in St. Augustine is Antonio’s New York Style Pizza. Celebrated for its handcrafted pies, Antonio’s brings an authentic New York pizza experience to the heart of Florida. From the classics like Margherita to innovative creations that cater to the modern palate, Antonio’s prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients to craft pizzas that resonate with authenticity and flavor. Beyond pizza, their menu expands to include subs, calzones, and other Italian favorites, making it a perfect spot for variety seekers.
Why These Hidden Gems Stand Out
The magic of St. Augustine’s lesser-known pizza spots lies in their ability to offer something unique to each visitor. Be it the lure of dining by the ocean at Romano’s or delving into a handcrafted New York-style pizza at Antonio’s, these pizzerias provide an unmatched dining experience that goes beyond the dish itself. They embody the spirit of St. Augustine – a blend of history, culture, and innovation – served up slice by slice.
The diversity in St. Augustine’s pizza scene allows for a culinary journey that’s rich in flavors and experiences. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, exploring these hidden gems offers a deeper appreciation for the city’s vibrant food culture. Each visit promises not just a meal, but a story to tell, of pizzas handcrafted with passion and places that resonate with the city’s timeless charm.
As the quest for the best pizza continues, these lesser-known establishments remind us that sometimes, the finest slices are found off the beaten path, waiting to be discovered. So, the next time you’re in St. Augustine, venture beyond the familiar and enjoy the pizza and stories these hidden gems have to offer.
Why St. Augustine’s Pizza Scene Stands Out
St. Augustine, Florida, isn’t just a treasure trove of history and stunning seaside views; it’s also a gastronomic destination, especially for pizza lovers. The city’s pizza scene is as diverse as its history, offering everything from traditional New York-style slices to authentic Italian wood-fired pies. But what makes the pizza stores in St. Augustine truly stand out? Let’s dive into the ingredients that make the city’s pizza offerings not just meals, but experiences.
Authentic Ingredients and Diverse Menus
One of the defining features of St. Augustine’s top pizza spots is their commitment to authenticity and quality. Pizza Time, for instance, delights diners with its Brooklyn-style pizza, drawing in crowds eager for a taste of New York in the heart of Florida. Meanwhile, Carmelo’s Marketplace offers a variety of toppings and authentic Italian dishes, illustrating the rich culinary diversity available in the city. From classic margherita pizzas to innovative gourmet options, the variety on offer ensures that every diner can find something to satisfy their cravings.
A Blend of Culinary Traditions
St. Augustine’s pizza places are a melting pot of culinary traditions. Viola’s Pizza, Pasta & Seafood stands as a testament to this blend, offering a menu that marries Italian cooking techniques with local seafood, creating unique dishes that can’t be found anywhere else. This fusion of traditions adds a distinctive flair to the city’s pizza offerings, making each visit a new adventure.
Passion for Pizza and Community
Beyond the dough, sauce, and toppings, what truly sets St. Augustine’s pizza scene apart is the passion of the people behind the pies. Many of these establishments, like Amici Italian Eatery and Antonio’s New York Style Pizza, are family-owned and operated, with recipes that have been passed down and perfected over generations. This passion extends to the community, with pizzerias often hosting local events and gatherings, fostering a sense of belonging and togetherness around the shared love of pizza.
Enduring Charm and Innovation
The pizza scene in St. Augustine is characterized by a unique blend of tradition and innovation. From the historic charm of restaurants like Pizzalley’s, located near the iconic St. Augustine fort, to the innovative approaches of newer establishments like Romano’s On The Beach, which combines picturesque views with inventive pizza offerings, the city’s pizzerias are continually evolving. This ensures that while they may pay homage to traditional methods and flavors, they are also not afraid to experiment and create new culinary experiences for their customers.
In every slice, St. Augustine’s pizza stores encapsulate not just the flavors of fresh, quality ingredients but also the spirit of the city itself. The diversity, passion, and innovation found within these establishments offer residents and visitors alike a rich, flavorful journey through the city’s culinary landscape. As they continue to evolve and adapt, one thing remains constant: St. Augustine stands out as a must-visit destination for any pizza enthusiast.
